I went looking for Florence McFadden expecting a footnote and found a woman with her own stage billing and a contradictory paper trail. She was born in Jersey City in the first days of January 1902, danced in the Ziegfeld Follies, and married the man who became the Tin Man.
A Jersey City Childhood And Two Possible First Days
The year holds. The place holds. The day does not. One record gives January 1, 1902, another January 2, and I leave both on the table. Her parents were James Frederick McFadden, about 30, and Katherine Cecelia McDonough, about 27, names that survive through a compiled birth index. A girl from Hudson County with a dancer’s ambition had few open doors. She chose the stage door.
The Ziegfeld Stage And A Billing Of Her Own
Florence McFadden was a Ziegfeld Follies dancer, and that line is the spine of her professional life. Later she partnered with her husband in a vaudeville act billed as Haley and McFadden, two names joined by an ampersand. In 1928 she appeared with him in a Vitaphone short called Haleyisms, reel 2269, billed as his wife Flo McFadden. That is her clearest screen credit under her own name. After the early sound years the trail goes quiet. By the late 1930s she appears in family photographs at home, and from there the public story is the household.
A Marriage With Three Conflicting Dates
Here the record becomes a knot. Four claims survive, and none agree.
| Claim | Date or span | What it implies |
|---|---|---|
| Marriage year | 1921 | Early union |
| Years married | 58 | About 1921 |
| Years married | 52 | About 1927 |
| Manhattan license | November 18, 1930 | A later union |
One account gives February 25, 1921, and a memorial inscription counts 58 years, which lands near 1921. His 1979 obituary said 52 years, pointing to about 1927. A Manhattan record dated November 18, 1930 sits off to the side like a guest who arrived at the wrong party. I read it this way. A daughter was born in January 1923, and a 1928 film already called Florence his wife. An early 1920s marriage fits both. The 1930 license does not, so I treat it as a conflict.
The Man She Married And The Role That Outlived Him
Jack Haley was born in Boston on August 10, though the year is given as 1898 and 1899. He died on June 6, 1979, at UCLA Medical Center after a heart attack on June 1. The funeral was at the Church of the Good Shepherd, and Ray Bolger delivered the eulogy. Jack is buried at Holy Cross Cemetery in Culver City. In 1939 he played the Tin Man and the farmhand Hickory, and that role swallowed the rest of his reputation whole.
Two Children And The Branches They Grew
Gloria Gertrude Haley was born on January 5, 1923, in Boston and later became Gloria Haley Parnassus. She appeared in several films in the 1950s, then became a full-time mother and did charity work with Betty White. She dated Mickey Rooney, Tom Drake, and DeForest Kelley, married the composer and producer Buddy Bregman, and later Dr. William Parnassus. She died on May 1, 2010, in Santa Monica. One notice said 83, but a January 1923 birth makes her 87, and I trust the birth date. She left two children, Barry Bregman and Adrienne Becker, and two grandchildren, Bernie and Adam Bregman.
Her brother, John Joseph Haley III, known as Jack Haley Jr., was born on October 25, 1933, in Los Angeles, and became a director and producer. He produced an early Biography series with David Wolper, directed Norwood in 1970, and shaped That’s Entertainment! in 1974 and The Wonderful Wizard of Oz: 50 Years of Magic in 1990. He won Emmys for Movin’ with Nancy in 1968 and the 51st Academy Awards telecast in 1979. He married Liza Minnelli on September 15, 1974, and they divorced in 1979 with no children. He died on April 21, 2001, in Santa Monica, of respiratory failure, at 67. Minnelli said he was the first to remind the public of its heritage, and that America’s royalty is its entertainers.
The Last Years And A Date That Will Not Sit Still
Florence outlived her husband, and the record of her ending is another small storm. Her death is placed on December 30, but the year is either 1986 or 1996, at 84 or 94. State death records and Social Security records point to 1996, and the middle initial fits the Catherine Florence form. A cemetery display says 1986. Her daughter’s 2010 obituary calls her the late Florence Haley, which proves only that she died before May 2010. She is buried at Holy Cross beside Jack, and the inscription is one word: WIFE. A life reduced to a marital status carved in stone.
FAQ
When was Florence McFadden born?
January 1 or 2, 1902, in Jersey City, New Jersey. The year is firm. The day is not.
Who was she married to?
Jack Haley, born John Joseph Haley Jr., the actor who played the Tin Man in 1939. They married in the early 1920s.
Did she appear in The Wizard of Oz?
No. She is not credited as a principal. Her screen credit is the 1928 short Haleyisms, where she appears as Flo McFadden.
How many children did she have?
Two. Gloria Gertrude Haley, born in 1923, and Jack Haley Jr., born in 1933.
Was Liza Minnelli her daughter?
No. Minnelli was her daughter-in-law, married to Jack Haley Jr. from 1974 to 1979.
When did Florence McFadden die?
December 30, in either 1986 or 1996. The death indexes favor 1996. She is buried at Holy Cross Cemetery in Culver City.